deviant art

Deviant Login Shop  Join deviantART for FREE Take the Tour
[x]
more ▶

Featured in Groups:

Details

October 27, 2009
Link
Thumb

Statistics

Comments: 52
Favourites: 0
Views: 244 (2 today)
[x]

On thanking people

Journal Entry: Tue Oct 27, 2009, 3:46 PM
Although I'm a lazy shit about replying to comments, I generally make sure to visit everyone's page who watches/collects something I've drawn... Sometimes, I see comments on userpages from very, very popular users (think 1mil+ pageviews) saying thank you for faving an image. Considering the amount of faves these people get on each deviation they submit, the amount of commenting and page-visiting these people must do is insane. There's only so many ways to say "thank you for the fave" so after a while it's just saying the same five words over and over again, and for the sake of their fingers I can only assume it's copied and pasted. While I have no real feelings on the matter either way (except that I am rather awestruck at the amount of time it must take to comment on 20k+ watcher/fave messages), I wonder how people who get the comments see it: Is it nice to see such a popular artist is still down to earth enough to pay individual attention to each person who likes their work, or is it just emotionless copypasta with no real meaning behind it except to broaden ones exposure?

CSS Journal Coded by ~FleX177
Add a Comment:
 
:icontala-twilight:
I usually delete them off my notices, to be honest. It's nice, but unless the artist just got a DD and therefore an unexpected flood of faves and comments besides mine, I don't typically give it a second glance. The only occasion I double check is when the thanker also links to the deviation I faved, and on those occasions I check them out to see if there's anything else in their gallery I may like.
Reply
:iconandrea-koupal:
It depends on the individual, but yeah, I'm sure some artists do it for the exposure. Artists with far too much free time on their hands. XD
Reply
:iconkevotu:
Personally ( Not someone with 1mil views and whatnot though xD ) I try to make the effort to thank people because I'm very grateful of the :+fav: , but it's hard to convey genuine appreciation through the internet, so I don't think the reasoning behind it actually matters ._.
Reply
:iconjustyne:
To be honest, I think the whole "thanking for the fav" business is a bit silly. I don't fave people expecting something in return and those who do (in my opinion) should probably re-evaluate their views.

If I take the time to write a long critique , I appreciate hearing back, but even in that context it is far from mandatory.

So really, I'd prefer if people didn't bother, but since it does no harm I suppose those who want to give thanks can.
Reply
:iconharripelle:
I like to get thanked. And sometimes I feel like I'm commenting to get some exposure. That doesn't make me feel very proud. Faves on the other hand I give to pieces I really like. At the moment I'll take any pasta thank you.
Reply
:iconsoolayah:
All that copypasta just feels like a massive waste of time. I suppose it's polite... but I've never cared either way if I get them or not.
If I watch/fave/etc it's for purely selfish reasons - I want to keep track of their/the art. It doesn't feel like it warrants thanks. |:
Reply
:iconmero-ix:
I feel the same way, like.. I'm grateful, but there's only so many ways I can say "thanks" so I don't say it to every single person or else it'll just come off as shallow.. I take each comment I receive on its own--if I have something to say, I'll reply. If not, I won't. I do visit everyone's page who watches me, though. And if I like their work I'll leave a comment. I know that I appreciate the comments and favs I get, and to me that's enough. I don't feel like I have to "prove" it to everyone.
Reply
:iconyakkingyetis:
i appreciate the effort anyhow as i don't thank everyone anymore :D :iconjmonzani: replies every message differently.. he really nice i must say
Reply
:iconangilram:
*Angilram Oct 28, 2009  Professional Digital Artist
It's very kind and polite to say than you for favs. Me, I don't really like to just type "thanks for the fav", as you said, it's just the same words. Instead, whenever I see someone who likes my work, I'll try to check their pages. But mainly, I stick with comments. I answer all comments and try to take a peek at people's page and leave a comment myself.
Reply
:icontwelfth:
I am really, really shocked by the amount of people saying things along the lines of "it's awkward!" or "it's uncalled for!" or "it's just stealing attention!" or anything like that. I mean jesus christ, when I thank people, which I admit isn't often, I do it because I'm grateful that they took the time to look at my work and give a crap about it.

Are people so jaded that they assume me thanking them is just a ploy to draw more attention to my page? Ouch. Well, at least I've learned something from this journal.
Reply
Add a Comment: